September #InkRipples – Banned Books
Reader #1: “I’m offended by teens having sex. They shouldn’t
allow those books into school libraries. Our teens might learn to have sex from
them.”
Reader #2: “I don’t care if teens have sex as long as they
aren’t the same gender. That might encourage an otherwise straight kid to be
gay.”
Reader #3: “At least sex is a natural thing. What I can’t
handle is if the teens are magic. What if it teaches people to try magic and
they end up in Hell because of it? ”
Okay, I seriously have to stop. I’m just pissing myself off
trying to come up with all the ignorant ways people condone book banning.
September 25 – October 1, 2016 is Banned Books Week. It is an
annual event that celebrates the freedom to read. Read that sentence and more
on this article about Banned Books Week: http://www.ala.org/bbooks/bannedbooksweek
Some of the banned books I’ve read include scandalous titles
such as:
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time by Mark
Haddon banned or challenged for reasons of offensive language,
religious viewpoint, unsuited for age group, and other (“profanity and
atheism”).
An Abundance of Katherines by John Green, banned or
challenged because it contained sexual references.
The Absolute True Story of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman
Alexie, banned or challenged because of the use of the word scrotum. (Oh, wait?
Can I use that offensive word?)
Eleanor & Park by Rainbow Rowell, a book that made me
laugh out loud and giddy as a schoolgirl was banned or challenged because of
its use of profanity and its treatment of sexuality.
Hop on Pop by Dr. Seuss. Yes, you read that right. Parents
wanted it removed from libraries because it promotes violence.
There are so many books that are challenged that we never
know about because some small-minded person felt they should make a decision
for all of us. Chances are you’ve read a banned or challenged book without
realizing that title has experienced strife somewhere in the world.
As I’ve navigated this crazy job of parenthood, I’ve run
into different subject matters that I didn’t want my children exposed to until
their maturity developed. I suggested titles they should read and shouldn’t
read along the way. THAT, ladies and gentlemen is the key. If you don’t want
your child exposed to the word scrotum YOU can exercise your parental right to
keep the book out of your child’s hands. However, YOU can’t make that decision
for my child. For all you know we have words like scrotum, penis, and vagina
stenciled on our bathroom walls to assure our children grow up knowing the
different body parts. It’s not your place to decide if that’s right or wrong
for MY children.
And—just a suggestion—when you’re reading Hop on Pop with
your child—I don’t know—maybe you can have a quick conversation about how that
would really feel to jump on a person’s stomach.
Supervision. Communication. PARENTING.
So, come on, live a little. Read a banned book to celebrate
the right to read. Read it with/to your children and have an open conversation
about the character’s excessive use of profanity or the consequences of having
sex/doing drugs/being a bully. Be a parent and open your mind and the minds of
those fine young people you are raising.
What banned books have you read? What title do you plan to
read this year to celebrate the right to read?
Ripples in the Inkwell is a themed meme hosted by Mary Waibel, Katie L. Carroll, and Kai Strand posting on the second Monday
of every month. To participate compose your own post regarding the theme of the
month, and link back to the three host blogs. Feel free to post whenever you
want during the month, but be sure to include #inkripples when you promote so
readers can find you. The idea is that we toss a word or idea into the inkwell
and each post is a new ripple. There is no wrong interpretation. Themes and
images and more information can be found here.
I've read all the books you mentioned except The Curious Incident. I didn't realize that Hop on Pop was a banned/challenged book!
ReplyDeleteIt's crazy what people will try to get a book banned for, isn't it? Promotes violence...scoff! Curious Incident is a good book.
DeleteBan it and I'll read it. I felt that when when I was a teen and feel that way now. If I don't like a book, guess what? I can stop reading it. But for heaven sakes don't try to keep me safe from ideas that might offend. Seriously?
ReplyDeleteI agree 100%, Lee! We have to power to 'ban' something by not putting our money behind it.
Delete